Stage 07

Multi-criteria scoring and ranking

The PROTO-NOOS score combines signals from the previous stages into a single deterministic number in the range [0, 1], and the rank that follows from it.

Construction#

Each quantity is first passed through a desirability function onto a common dimensionless scale, then blocks are summed with weights. The objective function is defined by one explicit schema and we report the effective weights.

Score v2#

In variant v2 the objective has two active blocks:

The molecular dynamics block acts purely as a gate, with an effective weight of zero. Compared to earlier variants, score v2:

The variant was selected by analysing 16 configurations over 1,003 records with measurements, and its stability was checked with 200 weight perturbations of ±20%. When a block is unavailable its weight disappears and the remaining weights are renormalised.

Calibration against experimental data#

MethodSpearman rhoROC AUCPR-AUC
Score v20.7050.8750.931
Affinity only0.6970.8580.924

On a shared cohort of 1,003 records with a pActivity measurement, score v2 outperforms affinity alone on all three measures. This is a retrospective validation of a variant chosen on that same cohort, not a result on an untouched test set.

On the whole-cell endpoint, growth inhibition of E. coli, the same change lowers ROC AUC to 0.483. No single objective function dominates on both available endpoints. Full comparison: DHFR campaign results.